31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Lecture



If a complex electrical circuit contains a single branch with a nonlinear resistor, the current in that branch can be determined on the basis of the active two-terminal network theorem (the equivalent-generator method). The idea of the solution is as follows. The branch containing the nonlinear resistor is separated from the original circuit, and the remaining, now linear, network is represented as an active two-terminal network (ATN). According to the ATN theorem, the linear ATN, as seen from terminals 1-2 of the separated branch (see Fig. 1,a), can be represented by an equivalent generator (see Fig. 1,b) with an EMF equal to the voltage 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques at terminals 1-2 with the branch containing the nonlinear resistor open-circuited, and with an internal resistance equal to the input resistance of the linear two-terminal network.

The resulting circuit is calculated, for example, by the graphical method, as a circuit with series-connected elements.

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

If it is also necessary to find the currents in the linear part of the original circuit, then after calculating the nonlinear circuit of Fig. 1,b, in accordance with the compensation theorem, the nonlinear resistor is replaced by an EMF or current source, after which the resulting linear circuit is analyzed by any known method.

Analytical calculation methods

It is convenient to study the general properties of nonlinear circuits on the basis of mathematical analysis relying on an analytical expression for the characteristics of nonlinear elements, i.e., their approximation. The choice of analytical method is influenced by the conditions of the problem at hand, as well as by the nature of the possible movement of the operating point along the characteristic of the nonlinear element: over the entire characteristic or within a relatively small region of it.

The analytical methods include:

  • the analytical approximation method;
  • the piecewise-linear approximation method;
  • the linearization method.

The analytical approximation method is based on replacing the characteristic (or a portion of it) of the nonlinear element with a general analytical expression. The following types of analytical approximation are used:

  • a power polynomial (see Fig. 2,a);
  • transcendental functions (exponential, hyperbolic, etc.) (see Fig. 2,b).

The coefficients (a,b,c,…) are chosen so as to give the best fit of the analytical expression to the working portion of the nonlinear characteristic. In doing so

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

the most characteristic points through which the analytical curve must pass are selected. The number of points equals the number of coefficients in the analytical expression, which makes it possible to determine the latter uniquely.

It must be remembered that when several roots of the nonlinear equation are obtained, they must be checked for whether they satisfy the problem. Suppose, for example, that in a circuit consisting of a linear resistor R and a nonlinear resistor connected in series, the I-V characteristic of the latter can be approximated by the expression 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . Determine the current in the circuit if the EMF source E ensures that the circuit operates in the first quadrant.

According to Kirchhoff's second law, the following equation holds for this circuit

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

or

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

The roots of the equation

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

The solution to the problem is 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , since the second solution 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques does not satisfy the conditions on physical grounds.

The piecewise-linear approximation method is based on representing the characteristic of a nonlinear element by straight-line segments (see Fig. 3), as a result of which the nonlinear circuit can be described by linear equations with coefficients that are constant within each segment.

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

When a circuit contains two or more nonlinear resistors, implementing this method is difficult, since in the general case it is not known in advance which segments of the piecewise curves the operating points lie on.

Piecewise-linear approximation can be implemented using the method of sectional piecewise-linear functions, which makes it possible to describe the broken-line curve by a single general analytical expression. For example, for the curve shown in Fig. 4 and defined by the coefficients 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques and 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques characterizing the slope of its individual straight-line segments, and the parameters 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , characterizing the coordinates of the points where the function values change abruptly, this expression will have the form

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Here the first two terms on the right-hand side define the first sloped segment of the approximated curve; the first three terms define the first sloped segment together with the first jump; the first four terms define the first and second sloped segments together with the first jump, and so on.

In the general case, the approximating expression obtained by the method of sectional piecewise-linear functions has the form

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

The linearization method is applicable for analyzing nonlinear circuits under small deviations of the operating point P (see Fig. 5) from its initial state.

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

In the vicinity of the operating point 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques (see Fig. 5)

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ,

where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques (Ohm's law for small increments);

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques -differential resistance.

The idea of the method is to replace the nonlinear resistor with a linear one whose resistance equals the differential resistance at the given (or assumed) operating point, together with either a series-connected EMF source or a parallel-connected current source. Thus, the linearized I-V characteristic (see the straight line in Fig. 5) corresponds to a series (Fig. 6,a) or parallel (Fig. 6,b) equivalent circuit of the nonlinear resistor.

If the initial operating condition is known and it is only necessary to calculate the increments of currents and (or) voltages caused by a change in the source voltage or current, it is expedient to use equivalent circuits for the increments, obtained on the basis of Kirchhoff's laws for small increments:

  • -Kirchhoff's first law: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ;
  • -Kirchhoff's second law: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

When constructing the circuit for the increments:

1) all EMFs and source currents are replaced by their increments;

2) nonlinear resistors are replaced by linear ones with resistances equal to the differential resistances at the operating points.

It must be remembered that the total value of any current or voltage in the circuit equals the algebraic sum of the initial value of the variable and its increment calculated by the linearization method.

If the initial operating condition of the nonlinear resistor is unknown, an operating point on its I-V characteristic should be assumed and, after performing the corresponding linearization, the calculation should be carried out; at its conclusion it is necessary to check whether the results correspond to the chosen point. If they do not match, the linearized segment is refined and the calculation is repeated, and so on until the required convergence is achieved

Iterative calculation methods

The solution of the nonlinear equation (system of nonlinear equations) describing the state of the electrical circuit can be obtained by approximate numerical methods. The solution is found as follows: based on an initial, sufficiently rough, estimate, the starting value of the root (roots) is determined, after which it is refined according to the chosen algorithm until it falls within the specified error tolerance.

The methods most widely used in electrical engineering for the numerical calculation of nonlinear resistive circuits are the simple iteration method and the Newton-Raphson method, the basic information about which is given in Table 1.

Table 1. Iterative calculation methods

Calculation sequence

Simple Iteration Method

1.The original nonlinear equation of the electrical circuit 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques is the unknown variable, is represented in the form 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

2. The calculation is carried out using the algorithm 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques - iteration step.

Geometric illustration of the algorithm

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Here 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques - specified error tolerance

Iteration convergence condition

On the interval between the approximate and exact values of the root, the inequality must hold 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Note

1.The initial approximation 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques is usually found from the equation 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques by neglecting the nonlinear terms in it.

2. The method can be extended to a system of nonlinear equations of order n. For example, when solving a 2nd-order system

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

the iteration formulas have the form 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ; 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

3. When solving a system of equations, convergence is usually checked during the iteration process.

Calculation sequence

Newton-Raphson Method

1. Based on the original nonlinear equation of the electrical circuit 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques is the unknown variable, the iteration formula 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques is written, where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques - iteration step.

2.Using the formula obtained, the iterative calculation is carried out

Geometric illustration of the algorithm

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Here 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques - specified error tolerance

Iteration convergence condition

On the interval between the approximate and exact values of the root, the inequalities must hold 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Note

Notes 1, 2, and 3 for the simple iteration method also apply to the Newton-Raphson method. In this case, when solving a 2nd-order system 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

the iteration formulas have the form

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

where

31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques

Review Questions and Problems

Answer: P=2 W.

Answer: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

Answer: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ; 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

Answer: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .

  1. How are circuits with one nonlinear resistor and an arbitrary number of linear resistors calculated?
  2. What are the advantages and disadvantages of analytical calculation methods compared to graphical ones?
  3. What analytical methods are used to calculate nonlinear resistive DC circuits?
  4. What is the essence of the linearization method? For solving which two types of problems is it used?
  5. What are equivalent circuits for increments? How are they constructed?
  6. What is the sequence for calculating nonlinear circuits by iterative methods?
  7. A nonlinear resistor is located in the diagonal of the bridge, whose I-V characteristic is approximated by the expression 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , where 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . The linear resistances of opposite arms of the bridge are pairwise equal: 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ; 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . Determine the power dissipated by the nonlinear resistor if the circuit is fed from a source with EMF 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .
  8. Determine the current in a circuit consisting of a linear resistor 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques and a nonlinear resistor connected in series, if the I-V curve of the latter 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques passes through the points with coordinates (15 V; 1.425 A) and (5 V; 0.325 A) and is approximated by an expression of the form 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . The EMF at the input of the circuit is 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques .
  9. In the circuit of the previous problem, the I-V characteristic of the nonlinear resistor is described by the expression (current in amperes, voltage in volts) 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ; 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques ; 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . Determine the voltage 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques across the nonlinear resistor and the current 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques through it using the Newton-Raphson method.
  10. In the circuit of Fig. 1,b 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques , 31. Nonlinear Circuit Calculation by the Equivalent Generator Method: Analytical and Iterative Techniques . The I-V characteristic of the nonlinear resistor is approximated by two straight-line segments, the first of which passes through the points with coordinates (0 V; 0 A) and (9 V; 2 A), and the second – through the points with coordinates (9 V; 2 A) and (12 V; 6 A). Determine the current in the circuit.

See also

  • [[b9870]]
  • [[b9895]]
  • [[b9865]]
  • [[b9926]]
  • [[b9929]]

See also

Comments

To leave a comment

If you have any suggestion, idea, thanks or comment, feel free to write. We really value feedback and are glad to hear your opinion.
To reply

Lectures and tutorial on "Theoretical Foundations of Electrical Engineering"

Terms: Theoretical Foundations of Electrical Engineering